new bedding...need help!

i am having a very hard time figuring out what bedding to keep for the girls..this is the 3rd quilt i have had home in the last week!

-the first one had too much blue-green in it, i would have had to re-paint their room to match everything and the yellow rocker still would have looked out of place. so i took it all back!

-the second one (brighter one), i really like it with the yellow walls (color is butter from restoration hardware) and i have some cute ideas to use some old tops to make pillows to make and i have an extra pillow sham to updated their valance!

-the third one is another one for target's shabby chic collection, which i love and was the look i was going for in the first place, but it is a little boring, but softer...and the girls both told me they like it...not sure if it is because it is new or what. i didn't get the sham yet, because i just wanted to see what the bedding looked like with the butter walls.

so i need your help...which one do you think i should keep?

luau-bright pink


or the shabby chic-soft pink